Isaac Scientific Publishing

Annals of Advanced Agricultural Sciences

Is Intensive Farming Ethically Acceptable?

Download PDF (705.9 KB) PP. 15 - 29 Pub. Date: May 8, 2018

DOI: 10.22606/as.2018.22001

Author(s)

  • Michiel Korthals*
    Professor of Applied Philosophy, Wageningen University, Free University, Netherlands

Abstract

Intensive farming in which high chemical inputs deliver high outputs [23], is the object of severe criticism [29]. In this article firstly an ethical framework is presented to ethically evaluate intensive high input farming. The framework consists of six ethical criteria according to which farming styles or regimes can be evaluated. The six criteria are Can the farming and food style reduce hunger, poverty and malnutrition? Is it sustainable? Is it animal welfare friendly? Is it fair and just to farmers and others? Does it stimulate rural liveability? Is it consumer friendly: does it decrease the gap between production and consumption and does it connect positively with rural and urban areas? Secondly, in applying these criteria I evaluate the current dominant intensive farming, by analyzing prominent texts and data from international organizations. Finally, I will argue that the balanced fulfilment of the six ethical criteria comprise something like a fair representation of food and farming styles in science, governments and markets, that culminates in food democracy where gaps between consumers and producers are mitigated, bridged or deconstructed.

Keywords

Intensive agriculture; ethical evaluation; sustainability; consumer friendly; agro food democracy.

References

[1] Altieri, M. A., Fernando R.Funes-Monzote & Paulo Petersen, 2011, Agroecologically efficient agricultural systems for smallholder farmers: contributions to food sovereignty –Agronomy for Sustainable Development, Published online 14 December 2011, DOI 10.1007/s13593-011-0065-6

[2] Berne Declaration 2013, http://www.evb.ch/en/p9451.html

[3] British Hearth Foundation, 2013, Portion Distortion. How much are we really eating? London: BHF

[4] Cochrane, W., 1993, The Development of American Agriculture: A Historical Analysis, Univ. of Minnesota Press

[5] Coff, Ch., Barling, D., Korthals, M. (Eds.), 2009, Ethical Traceability in Communicating Food, Dordrecht: Springer

[6] Critser, G. (2003), Fat Land: How Americans Became the Fattest People in the World, Boston: Mariner Books

[7] De Schutter, O., (2010), Food Commodities Speculation and Food Prices Crisis, Briefing note 02, United Nations

[8] De Schutter, O., 2013, Interim report of the Special Rapporteur on the right to food, http://www.unhchr.ch/tbs/doc.nsf/0/3d02758c707031d58025677f003b73b9

[9] Driessen, C., and M. Korthals, 2012, Pig towers and in vitro meat: Disclosing Moral Worlds by Design, Social Studies of Science, 42, 6, 797-820

[10] Eide, A. et al (eds.), 1984, Food as a Human Right, Tokyo, Paris: United Nations University

[11] Ewers, R., J?rn P. W., Scharlemann, et al, 2009, Do increases in agricultural yield spare land for nature? Global Change Biology, Volume 15, Issue 7, pages 1716–1726.

[12] FAO (2010).The State of Food Insecurity in the World Addressing food insecurity in protracted crises. http://www.fao.org/docrep/013/i1683e/i1683e.pdf (accessed 27/08/2012)

[13] Fresco, L., 2013, Hamburgers in het Paradijs, Amsterdam: Bakker.

[14] Gaskell, G., et al. 2010. ‘Europeans and Biotechnology in 2010: Winds of Change?’

[15] Eurobarometer 73.1 on the Life Sciences and Biotechnology. Brussels: European Commission. http://ec.europa.eu/public_opinion/.

[16] Glover, D., 2010, Is Bt Cotton a Pro-Poor Technology? A Review and Critique of the Empirical Record. Journal of Agrarian Change, 10: 482–509. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-0366.2010.00283.x

[17] Gottlieb, R., A. Joshi (eds.), 2010, Food Justice, Cambridge: MIT

[18] Grievink, F-W., 2013, Erasmus Food Management Institute, efmi.nl

[19] Haen, D., 2013, The Paradox of E-Numbers: Ethical, Aesthetic, and Cultural Concerns in the Dutch Discourse on Food Additives, J Agric Environ Ethics

[20] Harrison-Dunn, Annie-Rose, 03-Feb-2014, Sustainability review: Huge growth of sustainable companies but developed nations dominate, Food Navigator

[21] Herring, R. J. (ed.), 2014, Handbook on Food, Politics and Society, Oxford University Press

[22] Holt-Gimenez, E., Raj Patel, 2009, Food Rebellions: Crisis and the Hunger for Justice, Cape Town: Pambazuku Press

[23] IAASTD, 2009, http://www.agassessment.org/

[24] Korthals, M., 2004, Before Dinner, Dordrecht: Springer

[25] Korthals, M. (Ed.), 2011, Genomics, Obesity and the Struggle over Responsibilities, Dordrecht: Springer

[26] Korthals, M., 2012, Ethische aanvaardbaarheid van Nudging voor Overheid en Bedrijfsleven, WUR, pp. 45, Essay in opdracht van Ministerie van Economische Zaken, http:wu.academia.edu/michielkorthals.

[27] Korthals, M., 2014,The food we eat: the right to be informed and the duty to inform, in: R. Chadwick, Mairi Levitt and Darren Shickle (Eds), The Right to Know and the Right not to Know, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

[28] Lang, T. and M. Heasman, 2004, Food Wars, London: Earthscan Books.

[29] Liberti, S., 2013, Land Grabbing. Journeys in the new colonialism, London: Verso Millstone, E., and T. Lang, 2008, The Atlas of Food, London: Earthscan

[30] Moss, R., 2013, Fat, Sugar, Salt, London: Allen Nestle, M., 2002, Food Politics: How food industry influences nutrition and health, Berkeley: University of California Press.

[31] O’Neill, J., A. Holland, and A. Light, 2008, Environmental Values, London: Routledge

[32] Oxfam Novib, 2013, Behind the Brands, behindthebrands.org

[33] Palmer, C., 2011. Animal Ethics in Context. Columbia University Press.

[34] Patel, R., 2008, Stuffed and Starved: The Hidden Battle for the World Food System, London: HarperCollins

[35] Pfeiffer, Dale Allen, 2006, Eating Fossil Fuels: Oil, Food and the Coming Crisis in Agriculture. Gabriola Island, BC, Canada: New Society Books.

[36] Pimentel, D., 2005, Environmental and economic costs of the application of pesticides primarily in the United States, Environment, Development and Sustainability, 7: 229–252

[37] Pinstrup-Andersen, P., and P. Sandoe (Eds.), 2007, Ethics, Hunger and Globalization, Dordrecht: Springer

[38] Roberts, R., 2008, The End of Food. London: Bloomsbury

[39] Schlosser, E., 2001, Fast Food Nation. New York: Perennial

[40] Sen, A., 2009, The concept of Justice, London: Lane

[41] Standage, T., 2009, An Edible History of Humanity, New York: Walker and Co.

[42] Stevens, C. J., Dise, N. B. Mountford, J. O. Gowing, 2004, Impact of nitrogen disposition on the species richness of grasslands, Science 303 1879-1875

[43] Stoop, W. A., N. Uphoff and A. Kassam (2002). A review of agricultural research issues raised by the system of rice intensification (SRI) from Madagascar: Opportunities for improving farming systems for resourcepoor farmers. Agricultural Systems, 71, 249-274.

[44] Tansey, G., 2008, The Future Control of Food: A Guide to International Negotiations and Rules on Intellectual Property, Biodiversity and Food Security, London: Earthscan Techniek in Nederland, TIN.nl.

[45] Thaler, R., C. Sunstein, 2009, Nudge: improving decisions about health, wealth and happiness, London: Penguin.

[46] Tittonell, P., 2013, Farming Systems Ecology. Towards ecological intensification of world agriculture, Wageningen: WU

[47] Tomich, Th, et al., 2011, Agroecology: A Review from a Global-Change Perspective, Annual Review of Environment and Resources, Vol. 36: 193-222

[48] UNCTAD, 2013, Trade and Environment Review 2013, A Wake up call. http://unctad.org/en/PublicationsLibrary/ditcted2012d3_en.pdf

[49] Uphoff, N., I. Anas, O.P. Rupela, A.K. Thakur and T. M. Thiyagarajan (2009). Learning about positive plantmicrobial interactions from the System of Rice Intensification (SRI). Aspects of Applied Biology, 98.

[50] Van Ittersum, M., et al., 2008. Integrated assessment of agricultural systems – A component-based framework for the European Union (SEAMLESS). Agricultural Systems, 96, 150–165.

[51] Van Swaay CAM, 2008, Butterfly ring in Europe: Methods, applications and perspectives, Biodiversity and Conservation, 17, 3455-3469.

[52] Wallace, H., 2010, Bioscience for Life? Who decides what research is done in health and agriculture? London: Genewatch

[53] World Bank, 2013, World Development Report , Washington: World Bank.

[54] Wrangham, R. 2009. Catching Fire. How Cooking Made Us Human. London: Profile